ear, Stearns & Company announced yesterday that
it had agreed to renew its lease at MetroTech Center in
Brooklyn instead of moving 1,500 jobs to Manhattan or New
Jersey. The announcement came after the city agreed last week
to restructure $4.8 million in tax exemptions from an earlier
subsidy deal.
The investment bank's chairman, James E. Cayne, said Bear,
Stearns had agreed to sign a 20-year lease with its landlord
at MetroTech, Forest City Ratner.
"We're thrilled it worked out the way it has," Deputy Mayor
Daniel L. Doctoroff said. "It's the right result for
everybody."
But the bank's decision did not come without some drama,
which began last summer after Bear, Stearns threatened to move
its 1,500 Brooklyn employees to less expensive space in New
Jersey unless the city provided an incentive package to move
them to Lower Manhattan.
City officials had balked at providing Bear, Stearns with
any subsidies beyond what the bank received in a $75 million
deal struck in 1997. The Bloomberg administration did not want
to set a precedent by providing incentives for a company to
move out of Downtown Brooklyn, even to beleaguered Lower
Manhattan.
Critics of corporate incentives called the investment bank
greedy. In 1991, after threatening to move to New Jersey, the
bank received a $36 million incentive package to move
employees to MetroTech.
Six years later, Mayor Rudolph W. Giuliani expanded the
deal to a $75 million package when the bank decided to build
its current headquarters, on Madison Avenue between 46th and
47th Streets.
Then last year, Bear, Stearns, which had a property tax
exemption for the Brooklyn offices, complained that it was
facing a sharp increase in costs in 2004 when the tax
exemption and the lease were set to expire.
The bank ultimately struck a bargain with its landlord. And
in an unusual arrangement reached last week with the city,
Bear, Stearns was allowed to convert $4.8 million worth of
unused sales tax benefits from its 1997 deal into $4.8 million
worth of property tax exemptions, according to a city
official.
The arrangement allows the bank to obtain the subsidies
more quickly, at what Mr. Doctoroff said was "some small cost
to the city." "By and large, it's a win-win," he said. "We
said all along that the era of corporate handouts to get
people to stay in New York is nearing its end."
Jonathan Bowles, research director of the Center for an
Urban Future, said he was happy to hear that the investment
bank would remain in Downtown Brooklyn. Still, he had some
misgivings.
"Given the city's severe fiscal problems, everybody has to
pitch in" by paying higher property taxes, he said. "But it
appears that Bear, Stearns has found a way out of
that."